Martha Stewart Programmable Air Fryer Oven Review: Is It Worth It?
Small-Kitchen Appliance Guide
Martha Stewart French Door Air Fryer Oven: Is It Worth the Counter Space?
This polished countertop oven promises more than basic air frying. The real question for a smaller kitchen is whether its roomy capacity and multiple cooking modes replace enough appliances to earn a permanent place on the counter.
This post may contain affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you purchase through my links, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Fast Answer
Worth it when it replaces clutter—not when it adds to it
The strongest reason to buy this model is not simply that it looks nicer than many air fryers. It is that one countertop oven may cover jobs currently handled by a toaster, toaster oven, basket air fryer, and sometimes the full-size oven.
Households that cook often
Especially useful when you regularly toast, reheat, bake, roast, or air fry and want those functions in one appliance.
Roomy, multipurpose interior
The oven-style cavity handles foods and cookware that do not fit comfortably inside a typical basket air fryer.
It is not a tiny appliance
A 34-quart oven needs real counter depth, open-door clearance, ventilation, outlet access, and storage for the accessories.
You already own an air fryer or toaster oven
If your current air fryer and toaster oven work well, this may become one more large appliance rather than a space-saving replacement.
My practical take: This oven makes the most sense when you can name at least two appliances it will replace. For a genuinely small kitchen, buying it for appearance alone is not enough reason to surrender the counter space.
At a Glance
What you should know before opening the retailer page
Product listings can change, so treat this as a decision guide and confirm the current specifications, included accessories, price, care instructions, and return terms before ordering.
| Product type | French-door air fryer toaster oven and countertop convection oven. |
|---|---|
| Published capacity | 34 quarts. |
| Cooking options | 12 built-in presets, including everyday functions such as air fry, bake, toast, reheat, pizza, dehydrate, proof, and slow cook. |
| Published fit examples | Up to six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, or family-sized air-fryer portions. |
| Approximate exterior size | Roughly 21.1 × 19.7 × 19.7 inches in current published coverage. Confirm the exact measurement order and current listing before buying. |
| Design detail | Two clear-view French doors and a digital control area with front-facing knobs. |
| Accessories | The listing notes multiple included cooking accessories. Confirm exactly what is included with the current color and seller. |
| Best small-space role | A permanent appliance station that replaces a separate toaster oven and basic air fryer. |
Small-Kitchen Reality Check
Do not measure only the metal box
An appliance can technically fit on the counter and still be frustrating or unsafe to use. You also need enough room to open the doors, remove hot trays, reach the controls, access the outlet, and maintain the manufacturer’s required ventilation.
Safety first: Follow the current product manual for clearance, surface, electrical, and supervision requirements. Do not place the oven where heat or steam could damage nearby cabinets, walls, cords, or decor.
See the Details
Take a closer look before giving up the counter space
Use the arrows or dots to view the design, controls, interior, and countertop scale before deciding whether this appliance fits your kitchen.
Use the arrows or dots to move through all five product images.
The Replacement Test
What would leave your kitchen if this came in?
“All in one” is only a space-saving benefit when older appliances actually leave the counter, cabinet, or home. Use this quick test before adding the oven to your cart.
Name the appliances it replaces
A separate toaster oven and basket air fryer are the most logical candidates. A basic toaster may also become unnecessary for some households.
Protect your prep surface
Do not allow the oven to take over the only counter area where you can chop, assemble meals, unload groceries, or set down hot cookware.
Plan where the accessories live
Racks, baskets, trays, and rotisserie pieces can become cabinet clutter unless you give them one reachable storage zone before the oven arrives.
Capacity That Matters
What can you realistically use it for?
The roomy oven-style interior is the clearest advantage over a small basket air fryer. Published product information says it can handle six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, and family-sized air-fryer portions.
- Fast family foods: chicken tenders, nuggets, fries, wings, and frozen snacks.
- Simple lunches: pizza, toasted sandwiches, quesadillas, and reheated leftovers.
- Dinner helpers: roasted vegetables, potatoes, chicken pieces, and side dishes.
- Baking and breakfast: toast, bagels, cookies, and smaller baked items that fit the approved cookware.
- Specialty settings: proofing, dehydrating, and slow cooking when those functions match your routine.
Cooking capacity does not guarantee identical results for every food. Check recent customer feedback and follow the manual’s recommended rack positions, temperatures, and batch sizes.
Choose the Right Format
French-door oven or basket air fryer?
Neither format is automatically better. The better choice depends on what you cook, how many people you feed, and how much counter space you can permanently spare.
Choose This Oven When
You want capacity and versatility
- You want to toast, bake, roast, reheat, and air fry.
- You cook larger portions or foods that need a flat tray.
- You want one appliance to replace a toaster oven and air fryer.
- You have a permanent counter location with safe clearance.
- You will use the broader preset selection regularly.
Choose a Basket Model When
You want a smaller, simpler tool
- Your main goal is quickly air frying smaller portions.
- You cook for one or two people most of the time.
- You need a smaller countertop footprint.
- You prefer one removable basket instead of several accessories.
- You already own a toaster or toaster oven you like.
Honest Tradeoffs
Pros and considerations
A useful review should make the reasons to skip a product just as clear as the reasons to buy it.
What stands out
- Combines multiple common countertop cooking functions.
- Roomier, flatter cooking area than many basket air fryers.
- French doors and clear windows make food easier to view.
- Can make sense as a toaster-oven and air-fryer replacement.
- More styled appearance than many black plastic appliances.
- Useful for smaller meals that do not require a full-size oven.
What to consider
- The large footprint may overwhelm a genuinely narrow counter.
- It needs operating clearance, ventilation, and a tray landing zone.
- Accessories create additional washing and storage needs.
- It may cost more than a basic basket air fryer.
- More presets can mean a short learning period.
- It is poor value when it duplicates appliances you plan to keep.
Decision Guide
Who should buy it—and who should leave it behind?
Consider buying it when…
- You want one permanent appliance for several everyday cooking jobs.
- You can remove a separate air fryer, toaster, or toaster oven.
- You cook for a small or medium household and need more room than a compact basket provides.
- You have measured the counter, doors, cabinets, outlet, and operating area.
- You prefer an appliance that looks intentional when left out.
Skip it when…
- Your only available counter is also your main meal-prep surface.
- You already own and use a good air fryer and toaster oven.
- You mainly air fry one or two small portions.
- You need an appliance that is easy to store after every use.
- You are choosing it mainly for the color, not the way you cook.
Final Verdict
Is the Martha Stewart air fryer oven worth it?
It is worth considering when it will replace at least two appliances you already use and you have a permanent, safely measured counter location. Its 34-quart capacity and multipurpose design give it more everyday range than a basic basket air fryer.
It is harder to recommend when you already own the same functions or when the oven would consume your only usable prep space. In a small kitchen, the best appliance is not the one with the most settings—it is the one that earns its footprint every week.
Confirm the current seller, measurements, accessories, specifications, price, ratings, care instructions, and return terms on Amazon before ordering.
Frequently Asked Questions
Questions to answer before buying
Is the Martha Stewart air fryer oven good for a small kitchen?
It can work in a small kitchen when it replaces multiple appliances and has a permanent location with the required clearance. Its 34-quart capacity means it should not be treated like a compact basket air fryer.
Can it replace a toaster oven?
Its toast, bake, broil, roast, reheat, and air-fry functions may allow it to replace a basic toaster oven for many households. Compare the foods and cookware you use most often before removing your existing appliance.
What fits inside the oven?
Published product information says it can hold up to six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, or family-sized air-fryer portions. Always use cookware and food quantities approved in the current manual.
Does it need to stay on the counter?
Its size and accessory set make it more practical as a permanent countertop appliance. Moving a large oven in and out of a cabinet may reduce how often you use it and can create a lifting or storage problem.
Is this better than a basket air fryer?
Choose this style for capacity, flat trays, toast, baking, and broader versatility. Choose a basket model for smaller portions, a smaller footprint, and a simpler air-frying routine.
What should I check on Amazon before ordering?
Confirm the seller, exact exterior dimensions, voltage, included accessories, available color, current price, recent reviews, care instructions, warranty information, delivery estimate, and return policy.
Continue the Kitchen Plan
Organize and measure before adding another appliance
These next steps help readers make the kitchen work better whether they buy the oven or decide to skip it.
